Choosing the right roofing material is one of the most important decisions a Colorado homeowner will make. Between frequent hailstorms, high-intensity UV exposure, and strong winds sweeping down the Front Range, your roof needs to be durable, long-lasting, and the right fit for your budget. That’s why so many homeowners ask an essential question: What is the cost difference between architectural asphalt shingles and metal roofing in Colorado?
At Summit Roofing Solutions LLC, we hear this question every week from property owners in Greeley, Loveland, and Windsor because homeowners want pricing clarity they can trust. As a family-owned Colorado roofing company with decades of experience, we know how to break down costs in a transparent, educational way. If you’re considering a re-roof or new installation, understanding the true financial differences between these two materials can help you make the most informed decision for your home and long-term investment.
Below, we cover everything you need to know about “What is the cost difference between architectural asphalt shingles and metal roofing in Colorado?” including material pricing, installation expenses, lifespan value, and how Colorado’s unique climate impacts your total cost of ownership.
Valued Professionals
“Everyone at Summit Roofing is wonderful to work with. Matt, Debi, and Brett were all very knowledgable and always responsive to my questions. Everyone on the roofing crew was nice and they were very hard working. They replaced our roof in just a day and a half. They did a great job of disposing of the old shingles and nails. We have not found a single nail in our yard. They happily handled everything with the insurance company. I would highly recommend the team at Summit Roofing to anyone!” Marissa West.
What Is the Cost Difference Between Architectural Asphalt Shingles and Metal Roofing in Colorado?
To answer this question clearly, it’s important to look at the full picture: upfront price, durability, maintenance, Colorado-specific weather risks, insurance considerations, and long-term return on investment. While architectural shingles and metal roofing are both excellent options depending on your goals, they differ significantly in initial cost and long-term value.
Understanding Material Costs
Before diving into specific price ranges, it helps to understand why these two materials vary so dramatically in cost. Architectural asphalt shingles are mass-produced, easier to install, and widely available. Metal roofing, whether steel, aluminum, or standing seam requires more specialized manufacturing and installation.
Here’s a breakdown of what is the cost difference between architectural asphalt shingles and metal roofing in Colorado from a materials standpoint:
Architectural Asphalt Shingle Pricing
The most common for Colorado homes, asphalt shingles are thicker, more durable, and more visually appealing than 3-tab shingles. They last between twenty to thirty years and offer better wind and hail resistance, an important factor for Colorado homeowners.
This type of shingle requires periodic repairs after hailstorms and occasional shingle replacement due to granule loss, curling, or cracking. They do have a lower replacement cost but may need replacing multiple times over decades
Material cost: Typically $120–$200 per roofing square (100 sq. ft.)
Total install cost: Usually $6.00–$8.50 per sq. ft.
Metal Roofing Pricing
Standing seam metal is the premium option, while metal shingles and corrugated panels fall slightly lower on the cost spectrum. Metal roofing is very low maintenance and rarely needs repair after storms. It has excellent long-term performance in extreme weather. Lasting between 40–60 years, homeowners often spend less with metal roofing, even though the initial investment is higher.
Material cost: Usually $300–$500+ per roofing square
Total install cost: Typically $10.00–$16.00 per sq. ft.
The biggest takeaway? Upfront costs are significantly higher for metal, but lifetime value can be much greater.
5 Ways Climate Impacts Roofing Costs
Understanding what is the cost difference between architectural asphalt shingles and metal roofing in Colorado also means understanding how Colorado’s weather affects pricing, performance, and long-term value. Here are five climate-driven factors that play a major role:
1. Hailstorms and Impact Resistance
Colorado ranks among the top states for hail damage claims. Architectural asphalt shingles (especially Class 4) offer solid resistance, but may still need replacement after severe storms. Metal roofing often withstands hail with little more than cosmetic dents, resulting in lower long-term repair costs.
2. High Winds Along the Front Range
Strong wind gusts rolling off the foothills can lift shingles or break seals. Architectural shingles typically hold up to 110–130 mph when installed correctly. Metal roofing systems often exceed this and remain securely interlocked, reducing the likelihood of storm-related replacements.
3. Intense UV Exposure at High Elevation
At Colorado’s elevation, UV radiation is stronger and causes faster degradation. Architectural shingles experience granule loss, fading, and brittleness over time. Metal roofing reflects UV rays and experiences minimal UV-related wear, contributing to its longer lifespan.
4. Freeze-Thaw Cycles
Rapid temperature swings, sometimes within a single day, cause expansion and contraction. Shingles can crack or lose flexibility as they age. Metal roofing handles thermal movement better due to its panel design and fastening systems.
5. Heavy Snow Loads
Colorado’s spring storms often drop large, wet snow deposits. Shingle roofs shed snow reasonably well but are more prone to ice dam issues. Metal roofing naturally sheds snow quickly, reducing ice buildup and structural stress over time.
How to Choose the Best Option for Your Home
When deciding between shingles and metal roofing, consider these factors:
- Your long-term plans for the home
- Budget and financing options
- Insurance premium savings
- Neighborhood aesthetics
- Personal preferences for style and color
- Colorado’s high likelihood of hailstorms
Both materials are excellent depending on your needs, but each tells a different financial story over time. If you’re looking for affordability and strong performance, architectural shingles remain the most popular choice. If you’re planning to stay in your home long term and want the strongest durability and best lifetime value, metal roofing is a top-tier investment.
Looking For A New Roof, Consider Summit Roofing Solutions, LLC
Understanding What is the cost difference between architectural asphalt shingles and metal roofing in Colorado? empowers you to make a roofing decision that protects your home, your wallet, and your peace of mind. At Summit Roofing Solutions LLC, our team is always here to guide you through material options, pricing, insurance navigation, and long-term planning. Whether you’re leaning toward architectural shingles or considering the switch to metal roofing, we’ll give you transparent, honest recommendations based on decades of building homes and roofs throughout Northern Colorado.
If you’re ready for a personalized estimate or want help comparing your options, give our friendly team a call. Your best roof and best experience starts here.
Summit Roofing Solutions, LLC
At Summit Roofing Solutions, LLC, we’re a locally owned and family-run roofing team delivering high-quality craftsmanship and trusted service across Greeley, Fort Collins, Loveland, and all of Northern Colorado. With decades of experience and deep roots in your community, we specialize in residential and commercial roofing, storm damage restoration, and full new construction projects—always treating every roof like it protects our own home. Whether it’s a hail-damaged roof, insurance claim repair, or a complete replacement, our priority is clear communication, clean job sites, and dependable timelines. Our reputation is backed by an A+ BBB rating, nearly 100 five-star reviews from satisfied clients, and hands-on support through every step—from inspection to project completion. You can find us serving Greeley here, and Fort Collins here. We’d love to give you peace of mind under your next roof.
